A report commissioned by the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania is likely to generate interest among all states with toll roads. The report in Pennsylvania, announced earlier this month, advocates replacing the toll plazas along the 545-mile Pennsylvania Turnpike with an all-electronic toll collection system.
The traffic toll study, drafted by two transportation consultancies -- Philadelphia-based McCormick Taylor Inc. , and Columbia, S.C.-based Wilber Smith Associates Inc. -- recommends the state replace all of its Turnpike toll plazas with overhead “gantries” to collect tolls while drivers maintain highways speeds. Drivers with the E-ZPass electronic toll collection system in their vehicle, would have the toll deducted automatically as they passed under the gantry. Drivers without an E-ZPass or other toll collection device, would have their license plates photographed and would be sent a bill via the mail. Drivers would no longer be able to pay tolls with cash.
The hard cost savings of such an implementation would come in large part through the phasing out of human toll collectors, which the report’s authors said would provide savings of about $5 million in the first year and as much as $21 million by the tenth year of the plan’s implementation. Estimates show electronic toll collection costs about 25 cents per transaction, versus $1 per transaction for a human-based interaction.
Those savings would offset the estimated $319 million to put the all-electronic system in place.
The report notes other savings by instituting an all-electronic toll collection system would include air quality improvements because drivers would no longer have to idle at toll plazas. The all-electronic system would also mean toll collections would be faster and easier for everyone.
If the recommendations from the report’s authors actually takes place, it’s unlikely the change would be implemented in full for at least five years, according to state officials. The news comes on the heels of a toll hike for non-E-ZPass users earlier this year. Motorists paying with cash have been assessed an extra 10 percent over their E-ZPass-using counterparts. Other states also offer incentives such as increased cash tolls to incent drivers to use electronic toll-collection devices. In Pennsylvania, the most recent increase for cash customers mean cash customers are now paying about 17 percent more than users with E-ZPass. Because of the hikes, E-ZPass use continues to rise.
Last year, nearly 61 percent of all tolls collected in Pennsylvania went through E-ZPass. That’s good, but not as good as some of its neighboring states. For instance, New Jersey collects more than 76 percent of tolls on the New Jersey Turnpike through E-ZPass. The more states adopt overhead toll collection system, the less time you, as drivers, will have to spend sitting in traffic jams at toll booths.